House with Voids

東京都世田谷区上馬, 2022—2024

The brief for a detached single family house in this typical residential street of Setagaya initially seemed rather straightforward. The task was to design a house where the family (a couple with a young child) could grow old in. “A house with character in its appearance, clarity in its layout, and a modern sense of spaciousness with ample light in its interior”.

Contradicting Clarity

Not long into the design process, however, the initial brief lost its clarity in endless negotiations between the clients` internal conflicts, the limitations of the site, and their budget. What followed was study after study, only to discover an increasing amount of inconsistent concerns and new wishes. Addressing these led to ever more contradictions such as the fact that while one dreamed of “a house that looks like a diamond”, the other insisted on right angles in the living spaces.

Just as we had come to the conclusion that we might be facing an impossible task, we stumbled upon a strategy that offered an unexpected solution for not only this particular situation, but perhaps many others across Tokyo, where similar circumstances abound.

Mass and Void

We propose a radical departure from the house as a roof and four walls with openings in them.
Local regulations impose a number of cutting planes in various angles and directions trimming down the maximum buildable volume to guarantee a certain amount of sunlight for all. Strictly following these regulations results in the crystalline mass the client craves. Consequently, the house is not an assemblage of discrete elements but a polished, polyhedral monolith out of which generous rectangular voids are then excavated: a tunnel for parking and playing; a living-dining room; a roof terrace. Supporting functions and ample storage space wrap around these three main spaces in a protective layer. Contradictions are resolved, yet deliberately kept visible as a play of contrasts: open versus closed; spacious versus dense; rectangular versus skew; clean versus messy. By opening up the house along the two diagonal axes, we can make use of the maximal depth of the site to create an unexpected sense of openness in a ‘diagonal dialogue’ with the surroundings.

Growing Old Together

The void on the ground floor extends the street into the house, isolating a separate-yet-connected space with its own entrance: Designed as the acoustically sealed study/office of the initial brief, its spatial independence lets it adopt new functions over time: a student studio for when the child comes of age; a rental unit for the future empty-nesters; a care-taker’s apartment for when the couple might need help in old age. This capability for a house to “grow” with its inhabitants might serve as a model not only in the rapidly ageing society this project is part of.
JN